philosophy
3 posts · all topics
-
Do people in different cultures disagree about what counts as knowing? The Gettier car case
A 2001 study suggested that East Asian and Western students judge a classic puzzle about knowledge differently, which seemed to threaten a basic method of philosophy. Larger replications found no such difference, and a 23-country study found the same judgement almost everywhere.
-
Why a harmful side effect looks intentional and a helpful one does not
In a 2003 experiment, most people said a chairman who knowingly harmed the environment did so intentionally, while most said one who knowingly helped it did not. The asymmetry has replicated, but what causes it is still argued over.
-
Would you plug into the experience machine? It depends where you start
Nozick's experience machine is often treated as proof that people value contact with reality, not just pleasant experiences. Surveys that reverse the scenario suggest much of the intuition may come from reluctance to leave whatever life you already have.