Knowledge Engine

Did parasites make sex worth the trouble?

·no read data

The idea

Sex is expensive. In a species with separate males and females, an asexual female produces only daughters, each of which can bear young, while a sexual female spends half her output on sons. All else being equal, an asexual lineage should double its share every generation. Yet sexual reproduction is the norm among animals and plants. Explaining why is one of the long-standing puzzles of evolutionary biology.

One family of answers borrows its name from Leigh Van Valen. In 1973, after several journals rejected the paper, he founded a journal, Evolutionary Theory, to publish “A new evolutionary law”, which argued from the fossil record that a group’s chance of extinction stays roughly constant however long it has existed. He called this the Red QueenRed Queen hypothesis The idea that species must keep evolving just to keep pace with the other species, such as parasites, that are evolving around them., after the character in Through the Looking-Glass who must keep running to stay in the same place: each species’ environment, made up largely of other evolving species, keeps getting worse.

W. D. Hamilton, in a 1980 paper in Oikos, applied this logic to sex. He suggested that parasites, which are short-lived and evolve fast relative to their hosts, could favour sex if they are virulent against specific host genotypes. In his models parasites keep adapting to whatever host type is common, producing cycles, and under some of these cycling conditions sexual populations achieve higher long-run fitness than asexual competitors. Recombinationrecombination The shuffling of genes from two parents into new combinations during sexual reproduction. helps because it keeps producing rare gene combinations that the parasites are not yet adapted to.

A concrete example comes from Potamopyrgus antipodarum, a New Zealand freshwater snail that has both sexual and asexual forms. In a 1987 Nature paper, Curtis Lively measured how common males were across populations as a proxy for how much sex was going on. The pattern did not fit the idea that sex is maintained by a variable physical environment, but it did fit selection from parasites.

Why it might change a decision

The hypothesis makes a time-lagged prediction that can be checked: an asexual clone should do well while it is rare, become the parasites’ main target once it is common, and then decline. Sexual hosts should not show the same boom and bust. Jokela, Dybdahl and Lively tracked a mixed population of sexual and asexual snails in New Zealand for ten years from 1994; the details here come from the university’s summary of the paper, as the full text could not be checked. Clones that were common at the start became more susceptible to parasites over time, and as infections rose they declined sharply, some disappearing entirely. The sexual snails stayed comparatively stable. For anyone designing a study, the idea says to look for shifting, genotype-specific infection over time, not a fixed advantage of sex at a single moment.

How solid is this?

The evidence combines theory, field surveys and one well-known laboratory experiment, but it comes from a small number of study systems.

The strongest experimental test is by Levi Morran, Olivia Schmidt, Ian Gelarden, Raymond Parrish and Curtis Lively, published in Science in 2011. The nematode worm Caenorhabditis elegans normally reproduces by self-fertilisationself-fertilisation Reproduction in which one individual fertilises its own eggs, so offspring get genes from a single parent. but can also mate with males. The team let worm populations evolve alongside the bacterial pathogen Serratia marcescens. Populations able to both self and outcrossoutcrossing Reproduction in which an individual mates with a different individual rather than fertilising its own eggs. ended up outcrossing much more often when the pathogen was coevolvingcoevolution Evolution in which two species, such as a host and its parasite, keep adapting in response to each other. with them. Populations genetically restricted to selfing were driven extinct quickly, while those restricted to outcrossing persisted as host and pathogen kept adapting to each other. This is direct, controlled evidence that a coevolving parasite can favour mixing genes from two parents, at least in this pairing. It does not show that parasites are why sex arose, and lab conditions are simpler than the wild.

The field studies are correlationalcorrelational Showing that two things vary together, without establishing that either one causes the other.. Snail populations differ in many ways besides parasite load, so a link between male frequency and parasites is consistent with the Red Queen without proving it.

The main competing explanation is about harmful mutations. Alexey Kondrashov argued in Nature in 1988 that if deleterious mutations arise at more than about one per genome per generation, sexual populations can purge them more efficiently than asexual ones. On this view sex is a cleaning mechanism, not an arms race. Other proposals emphasise changing physical environments, which Lively’s snail data did not support. The two ideas are not mutually exclusive, and how much each contributes in a given species is unresolved. The popular version, that parasites are the reason sex exists, goes further than the evidence; the narrower claim, that coevolving parasites can select for sex in real organisms, has good support.

Sources

  • Van Valen’s 1973 paper is described via: Solé, R. (2022). Revisiting Leigh Van Valen’s “A New Evolutionary Law” (1973). Biological Theory, 17, 120-125. doi:10.1007/s13752-021-00391-w
  • Hamilton, W. (1980). Sex versus non-sex versus parasite. Oikos, 35, 282-290. doi:10.2307/3544435
  • Lively, C. M. (1987). Evidence from a New Zealand snail for the maintenance of sex by parasitism. Nature, 328, 519-521. doi:10.1038/328519a0
  • Kondrashov, A. (1988). Deleterious mutations and the evolution of sexual reproduction. Nature, 336, 435-440. doi:10.1038/336435a0
  • Jokela, J., Dybdahl, M., & Lively, C. M. (2009). The maintenance of sex, clonal dynamics, and host-parasite coevolution in a mixed population of sexual and asexual snails. The American Naturalist, 174(S1), S43-S53. doi:10.1086/599080
  • Indiana University (2009, July 6). Asexual snails fall prey to parasites as they become common. ScienceDaily summary of Jokela et al. sciencedaily.com
  • Morran, L. T., Schmidt, O., Gelarden, I. A., Parrish, R. C., & Lively, C. M. (2011). Running with the Red Queen: Host-parasite coevolution selects for biparental sex. Science, 333, 216-218. doi:10.1126/science.1206360

Check yourself

Answers are checked in your browser. Nothing is recorded or sent anywhere.

  1. In Hamilton's 1980 models, what had to be true of parasites for sex to come out ahead of asexual reproduction?

  2. What happened to obligately self-fertilising C. elegans populations in the Morran et al. (2011) experiment when they faced a coevolving pathogen?

  3. What did Jokela, Dybdahl and Lively's ten-year snail study report about common asexual clones?

  4. Which is the fairest summary of the evidence described here?

Questions without answers

  1. The Red Queen predicts that the advantage of sex should be greater where parasites are more common. What would you measure, in a species other than snails or worms, to test that, and what result would count against it?
  2. If parasites and harmful mutations both favour sex and probably act together, is it meaningful to ask which one 'explains' sex? What would an answer even look like?

Back to the archive