The third kind of good life
Ask a psychologist what makes a life good and you will usually get one of two answers. The hedonichedonic Concerned with pleasure and feeling good, as opposed to purpose or meaning. answer: feeling good, meaning pleasure, satisfaction, the absence of suffering. The eudaimoniceudaimonic Concerned with purpose, meaning and living well, as opposed to feeling good moment to moment. answer: doing good, meaning purpose, contribution, a life that adds up to something. These two have structured the field for decades.
Shigehiro Oishi and Erin Westgate argue a third thing was quietly left out. They call it psychological richness: a life characterised by variety, interest, and experiences that change how you see things.
Their argument for why it was missed is structural rather than philosophical. Existing well-being measures map neatly onto four of the Big Five personality traitsBig Five The five broad personality traits most widely used in psychology: openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and emotional stability.: extraversion, emotional stability, conscientiousness, agreeableness. Openness to experienceopenness to experience The Big Five trait covering curiosity, imagination and appetite for new ideas and experiences. had no corresponding dimension. There was a hole in the grid, and richness is what fits it.
The part that is genuinely strange
Rich experiences do not have to be pleasant. They do not have to be purposeful either.
Westgate’s lab has tracked students through approaching hurricanes, sampling their emotions as the storms closed in. Many rated the experience as psychologically rich, because it changed how they saw the world, while plainly not enjoying it and while it served no purpose they had chosen.
That decoupling is the whole idea. It implies something uncomfortable about the other two dimensions: a happy, meaningful life can be monotonous. A steady job, a stable family, work that matters, all genuinely good by both conventional measures, and possibly very repetitive. The framework gives you a vocabulary for a dissatisfaction that otherwise sounds like ingratitude.
What it might change
It adds a third question to decisions that currently get two. Not just will this make me happy and does this matter, but will this change how I see things.
A related finding gives that a testable edge. Aaron Heller and colleagues combined GPS tracking with experience samplingexperience sampling A method that pings people at intervals during ordinary life to record what they are doing and feeling, rather than asking them to remember later. and found that days with more variability in physical location were days with higher positive affectpositive affect Psychologists' term for the experience of pleasant feelings such as enthusiasm, alertness and contentment.. The obvious experiment: deliberately vary where you spend time for a fortnight, log your mood, and see whether the pattern holds for you specifically. Individual results are the only ones you actually have access to.
How solid is this?
Mixed. It is worth being precise, because this is the kind of idea that travels faster than its evidence.
The constructconstruct In psychology, a thing researchers propose and then try to measure, such as intelligence or well-being, rather than something observed directly. is new and partly contested. Richness correlatescorrelational Showing that two things vary together, without establishing that either one causes the other. moderately with established eudaimonic measures: self-acceptance at r = .54, purpose in life at r = .47. Related but not identical, which is the authors’ point. Whether that gap represents a genuinely distinct dimension or a repackaging of openness is a live argument, not a settled one.
The Heller finding is correlational, and the authors say so. They describe the location and affect relationship as bidirectional. Feeling good is itself a reason to leave the house. Nobody has shown that engineering more variety into your week causes the mood improvement, and the study was not designed to. The neuroimaging arm rested on 58 participants, small for individual-differences brain work.
Independent prediction is weak where it has been tested. A study of 2,644 Facebook users attempted to predict all three well-being dimensions from language. Psychological richness came last, at r = .21, below both hedonic and eudaimonic well-being.
One correlate, reported neutrally. In Oishi and Westgate’s samples, happy and meaningful lives were associated with conservative worldviews, while psychologically rich lives were not. That is an observed association in particular samples. It is not evidence that any political orientation produces a better life, and I would read nothing prescriptive into it in either direction.
The honest summary: an interesting construct with suggestive cross-sectionalcross-sectional A study that measures everyone at a single point in time, which can show that two things go together but not that one causes the other. support, no causal evidence that pursuing it works, and open questions about whether it is distinct enough to need its own name.
Sources
- Oishi, S., & Westgate, E. C. (2022). A psychologically rich life: Beyond happiness and meaning. Psychological Review. PDF
- Heller, A. S., et al. (2020). Association between real-world experiential diversity and positive affect relates to hippocampal–striatal functional connectivity. Nature Neuroscience, 23, 800–804. Link
- Assessment of psychological richness, meaning, and happiness with social media text data (2026). PLOS ONE. Link