Knowledge Engine

Did the printing press make cities grow?

·no read data

The idea

Printing with movable type began in Mainz in the middle of the fifteenth century and spread across Europe within decades. It is often named as one of the great turning points in history. Yet economists who went looking for its effect on productivity or income per head in national data found very little. Jeremiah Dittmar, in a 2011 paper in the Quarterly Journal of Economics, notes that earlier work, including by Gregory Clark and Joel Mokyr, judged the aggregate effects to be small.

Dittmar’s move was to look at cities instead of countries. Using historical city population estimates compiled by Bairoch, Batou and Chèvre, he compared European cities that had a printing press by 1500 with similar cities that did not. Adopting cities grew about 60 percent faster between 1500 and 1600 than otherwise similar cities, and they had shown no growth advantage before printing arrived.

The obvious problem is that printers were not placed at random. They were businesspeople, and the paper itself finds they favoured larger cities. To get around this, Dittmar used each city’s distance from Mainz as an instrumental variableinstrumental variable Something that shifts the thing being studied but has no other route to the outcome, used to tell cause apart from mere association.. A concrete version: a town a short journey from Mainz was likely to get a press early simply because printers trained there and travelled outwards, while an otherwise identical town far away got one later or not at all. If distance from Mainz matters for growth only because it shaped access to printing, comparing near and far towns isolates the effect of the press.

Why it might change a decision

The study makes a specific, checkable claim about where to look for the effects of a new information technology. If Dittmar is right, early gains concentrate in the places that adopt first, and they can be invisible in national averages for a long time. That predicts that city or regional data should show adopting places pulling ahead after adoption, not before, while national productivity series stay flat. It also offers a test that any rival explanation has to pass: the growth gap should open only after the technology arrives.

How solid is this?

The city growth claim rests mainly on a single study, and the research for this post found no independent replicationreplication Running a study again, independently, to see whether the original result holds up. of its main estimate. It is observational, built on population estimates at 100 year intervals. The main balanced panel covers 202 cities, of which 83 adopted printing, with other regressions using between 291 and 622 cities.

The size of the effect depends on the method. Ordinary regression gives about 0.19 log pointslog points A way of measuring proportional change, where 0.1 log points is roughly a 10 percent increase for small changes. of extra growth from 1500 to 1600. The instrumental estimate is about three times larger, 0.58 log points, but with a standard error of 0.29, so the plausible range is wide. Dittmar argues the larger figure is expected, because a yes-or-no measure of adoption is a noisy proxy for how much print culture a city had. Placebo testsplacebo test A check that runs the same analysis where no effect should exist, such as before a change happened, to see whether the method finds one anyway. support the design: distance from Amsterdam, London, Paris, Venice or Wittenberg did not produce significant effects, and distance from Mainz did not predict growth before 1500.

The strongest competing explanation is religion. Jared Rubin, in the Review of Economics and Statistics in 2014, used the same instrument to study the Reformation. He found that cities with at least one press by 1500 were at least 29 percentage pointspercentage point The plain difference between two percentages, so a move from 40 to 45 percent is a rise of 5 percentage points. more likely to be Protestant by 1600. That is a finding about printing in its own right, but it complicates the growth result: if distance from Mainz shaped religion, and religion shaped growth, the instrument does not run through printing alone. Dittmar controls for distance to Wittenberg, where Luther began, and reports that the results hold, but a control of this kind cannot rule out every route.

There is also strong evidence that printing changed the book trade itself. Eltjo Buringh and Jan Luiten van Zanden, in the Journal of Economic History in 2009, estimated manuscript and printed book production across Western Europe over thirteen centuries. They found the sector grew at an average of around one percent a year, with output rising after the middle of the fifteenth century, which they attribute mainly to falling book prices and rising literacy. That supports a large change in access to information, not a specific effect on city growth.

Where the popular story outruns the data is in the jump from bigger cities to richer societies. City population is not income per head, and Dittmar does not measure the latter directly. The national evidence of small aggregate effects has not been overturned; Dittmar’s argument is that it missed local spillovers.

Sources

  • Dittmar, J. E. (2011). Information technology and economic change: The impact of the printing press. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 126(3), 1133-1172. doi:10.1093/qje/qjr035
  • Rubin, J. (2014). Printing and Protestants: An empirical test of the role of printing in the Reformation. Review of Economics and Statistics, 96(2), 270-286. doi:10.1162/REST_a_00368
  • Buringh, E., & van Zanden, J. L. (2009). Charting the “rise of the West”: Manuscripts and printed books in Europe, a long-term perspective from the sixth through eighteenth centuries. Journal of Economic History, 69(2), 409-445. doi:10.1017/S0022050709000837

Check yourself

Answers are checked in your browser. Nothing is recorded or sent anywhere.

  1. Why did Dittmar use each city's distance from Mainz in his analysis?

  2. What did the study find when it looked at the century before printing arrived?

  3. What did Rubin (2014) find using the same distance-from-Mainz instrument?

  4. Which is the fairest summary of the evidence that printing made cities grow?

Questions without answers

  1. The same instrument, distance from Mainz, has been used to explain both city growth and religious change. What would you need to know to decide whether it can do both jobs at once?
  2. Dittmar found effects in city populations while earlier work found nothing in national aggregates. For a modern technology, such as broadband, where would you expect its effects to show first, and why might national figures miss them?

Back to the archive