Do plants hold back their roots when growing next to siblings?
The idea
Animals that favour relatives are a textbook case of kin selectionkin selection Evolution favouring behaviour that helps relatives, because relatives carry many of the same genes.: helping a relative can pass on shared genes even at some cost to yourself. For plants, the idea long seemed out of reach. A plant cannot see or smell its neighbour in any ordinary sense, and much of its competition happens below ground, out of sight.
In 2007 Susan Dudley and her student Amanda File at McMaster University published a short paper in Biology Letters titled “Kin recognitionkin recognition The ability of an organism to treat relatives differently from unrelated individuals. in an annual plant”. They worked with the Great Lakes sea rocket, Cakile edentula, a small mustard that grows on sandy shores. They collected seeds from wild plants and grew them in groups of four, either all from the same mother plant (siblings) or from different mothers (strangers).
The key part of the design was the containers. Some groups shared one pot. Others grew in four separate small pots that held the same total volume of soil, so each plant had comparable resources but its roots could never touch a neighbour’s. After eight weeks the researchers washed the soil away and weighed the dried roots.
Strangers sharing a pot put more into roots than siblings sharing a pot; Science News reported the difference as about 15 percent. In the separate containers, relatedness made no difference. Because root growth helps a plant compete for water and nutrients underground, the authors read the pattern as plants competing less hard with family, which is consistent with kin selection, and they suggested root interactions as the likely cue.
Why it might change a decision
The finding matters most to people who plant things in dense stands. If plants restrain root competition when surrounded by relatives, then planting genetically related seed together could, in principle, shift resources away from roots and towards growth above ground or seed.
That makes a specific, testable prediction for agriculture or restoration planting: at the same density and soil, plots sown with seed from a single family or line should show lower root allocation and, if the idea pays off, higher seed or biomass yield per area than plots sown with mixed, unrelated seed. A 2021 review by Niels Anten and Bin Chen notes that this crop-yield benefit remains largely untested, so it is a prediction rather than an established practice.
How solid is this?
The original evidence was a single greenhouse pot experiment in one species, measured at the seedling stage. Its strengths are a simple and clever control: the separate-pot treatment rules out the possibility that siblings simply had different access to soil.
The weakness is measurement. When roots tangle, they often cannot be assigned to individual plants, so root mass gets measured for the pot as a whole. Larger plants then dominate the total. A 2008 comment in the same journal by Klemens questioned the analysis, and Dudley and File replied in a note titled “Yes, kin recognition in plants!” As the Anten and Chen review summarises the wider concern, size inequality is likely to be greater among unrelated neighbours, and that alone can tilt group-level averages, even when individual roots are measured, through Jensen’s inequality.
Since 2007 the idea has been tested many times. The review lists reports of kin responses in wild species such as Impatiens pallida, Arabidopsis thaliana and Douglas fir, and in crops including soybean, barley, rice and pea, with wheat contested. The record also contains nulls: in one study only one of eight co-occurring grassland species behaved less competitively with kin, and another found that relatedness among Arabidopsis accessions affected neither growth nor seed production. Effects on fitness are, in the review’s word, mixed.
The strongest competing explanation is that plants respond to how similar a neighbour’s roots or exudatesroot exudates Chemicals that plant roots release into the surrounding soil. are, not to relatedness as such, and that kin effects get tangled with niche differences, since unrelated plants may use soil differently and so compete less, not more. The review concludes that belowground kin recognition probably exists, but says its mechanism is poorly understood beyond a general role for root exudates, and that field evidence is still thin. The popular headline “plants recognise their family” therefore runs somewhat ahead of the data: what is well supported is a measurable change in root growth in some species under some conditions.
Sources
- Dudley, S. A. and File, A. L. (2007). Kin recognition in an annual plant. Biology Letters 3(4): 435–438. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2007.0232 (record: https://experts.mcmaster.ca/scholarly-works/287694)
- Dudley, S. A. and File, A. L. (2008). Yes, kin recognition in plants! Biology Letters 4(1): 69–70. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2007.0585 (record: https://experts.mcmaster.ca/scholarly-works/287708)
- Anten, N. P. R. and Chen, B. J. W. (2021). Detect thy family: Mechanisms, ecology and agricultural aspects of kin recognition in plants. Plant, Cell & Environment. https://doi.org/10.1111/pce.14011 (open copy: https://edepot.wur.nl/543149)
- Science News (2007). Easy there, bro: A plant can spot and favor close kin. https://www.sciencenews.org/article/easy-there-bro-plant-can-spot-and-favor-close-kin